PLL Episode 2x18 - A Kiss Before Lying

Clues in this Episode that Aria is A
When all four of the girls find -A's phone after they attack them, they have Caleb try and uncover some of what is hidden in it. All of the girls know that -A like to take away everything that is important to the girls so Hanna is worried getting Caleb involved. She finally agrees to let him work on it. Once Caleb uncovers some of the things on the phone, Hanna gets worried. She destroys the flash drive that Caleb has been working on and tells him to never work on it again. Caleb luckily made a copy of all of the files and agreed to keep working on it with Emily, Spencer, and Aria as long as Hanna didn't find out. After a few days of trying to uncover more things from the phone, Spencer starts to feel guilty and asks Aria is they're doing the right thing. Aria replies saying this: 

Aria: "There are just certain situations where you have to lie to your friends"

Sounds to me that Aria lies about an awful lot if she thinks it's OK to lie to her friends...Aria is not only lying to Hanna along with the other girls about working on the file, but also lying to all of her friends and her parents for seeing Ezra. Her parents already don't allow her to see Ezra so she sneaks out with a family friend to go and see him. She won't even tell her friends about seeing Ezra either. Looks like lying to her friends and family is second nature to Aria...doesn't sound like a very loyal friend to me! 
[2x15] Mona to Hanna: "Han, did you really order 12 pizzas with green peppers on them? Noel's allergic!"
[2x18] Holden to Aria: "Wanna get a large pizza to split? I'll even order your favorite, green peppers right?"
Hanna is throwing Caleb's surprise party and  Mona asks her "Han, did you really order 12 pizzas with green peppers on them? Noel's allergic!". Hanna admits to Mona and Noel that she did not order it. Hmm, I wonder who messed up the order? Looks like an -A move to me!! Three episodes later, Holden, an old family friend of Aria's, and Aria go out to an arcade. Holden knows that both of them were going to be there for a while waiting for their parents to come pick them up so he suggests that they order some pizza and play some games they enjoyed when they were little at the arcade. Holden remembers that Aria's favorite topping on her pizza is green peppers.  How ironic that -A and Aria love green peppers on their pizza! Remember that Aria couldn't go to Caleb's surprise party because she was grounded. Aria could have easily called and changed the order on the pizzas to mess with Hanna!
In the past two seasons, Noel Kahn has always been sort of a 'fishy' character. All the girls at Rosewood high love him and he's dated a few of them. SO far we know that he's dated Mona, Jenna, and Aria. In season four, we find out that Noel has been helping Ali the whole time and helping her get around in secret. He's also been trying to help her find out who is threatening her. Mona and Jenna we're two suspects of Ali's for torturing her and the girls. Since two out of the three girls that Noel's dated Ali was also worried that they were threatening her, do you think Noel only was dating them to get close to them to help Ali? Don't you think he would do that same for Aria? So that means that Ali feared that Aria was threatening her and the rest of the girls...

Songs in this Episode

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter @pllariatheory