PLL Episode 3x02 - Blood is the New Black

Clues in this Episode that Aria is A

Garrett Reynolds has recently been arrested for the murder of Alison and their other close friend Maya. All of the girls think that he has answers that he can give them about A and who else is involved in these murders. Garret is allowed visitors in jail so Spencer goes to visit him to try and get more informations about their dead friends. Spencer wants to know who is helping him, because at the time they thought that he was A, but we know that he isn't now. Garrett doesn't admit to Spencer that he is A, but he does know more valuable information about who might be threatening the girls. He begins to tell Spencer:

Garrett: "People lie, but medical records don't."

Obviously someone had medical records that people don't know about. They can obviously hide the records from others easily. I think it's Aria's medical records! No one suspects anything to be wrong with her, but there are just too many things that make it seem like she has a mental disorder! I think she was in Radley before the girls started getting the texts and no one found out about it. I think she was in there for her split personality disorder. There are just too many signs that point right to her that make it seem like she has a mental disorder! 
As we know, Aria's dad was involved with a younger women and cheated on her mom with the younger women. Aria goes to his office to see if she can prove that he is still seeing her. When she looks in the couch in his office, she finds a pair of earrings that she assumes belongs to Meredith. Aria goes crazy when she finds the earring and decides to trash her own father's office. The throws all of his papers on the floor and destroys his pillows. She also crosses his name out of some of the family pictures that he had has around his office. Ironically she uses a type of lipstick that we've seen before in some of the episodes. In 1x05, there was an A message written on Spencer's mirror in her room. Of course it was written in all Caps just like these messages Aria wrote all over her dad's Office. Also the lipstick is almost the exact same color as the other lipstick that was used to write an A message on Spencer's mirror! Aria also writes messages about her dad being a pig. We know from many episodes before that A loves to use pig references....
Since we know that A likes to make pig references when they torture the girls you can assume that A's favorite animal is definitely a pig!  We also know that Aria's favorite animal is definitely a pig. She always carries around a stuffed pig animal that she's had since she was a little girl. So obviously pigs are very important to her. A always seems to use pig references when they decide to torture the girls. I don't know many people that's favorite animal is a pig so it wouldn't surprise me since Aria and A both love pigs that Aria is A because not too many people love pigs as much as they do!

Jenna says to Aria: "Hey Aria! I was going to call you tonight."
Aria: "Oh really? Why?"
Jenna: "I lost my accompanist for next weeks assembly and I thought of asking you to play with me."

Jenna asked Aria to help her with a school project. Jenna is recording a song and she needs a piano player to help her. She knows that Aria is very good at playing the piano and she asked if Aria would help her. Aria of course lying again, says that she cannot help and that she has to go because her dad is waiting for which he isn't. This is the first time you're hearing that aria is good at playing the piano. What other character do we know that likes to play the piano? Of course it's A!  With all these things in common it seems like to me that Aria and A are the same person! Wouldn't surprise me!
Jenna Marshall had recently got an eye surgery to clear her blindness. She told everyone that the surgery did not work and that she could not see again. We are soon finding out that she actually can see. The girls have been suspicious of it ever since she got to surgery but haven't really come to the conclusion that she can see until that afternoon in the bathroom. They set an earring on the sink of the bathroom and hid in the stalls to see if she would pick it up and look at it. Of course she did so now the girls know that she can see again and are very upset because they thought that she couldn't. Aria at begins to get very angry and wants to go tell everyone that she can see. She says:

Aria: "I'm ready to tell everyone! Bitch can see!"


The girls later in episode 4x24, get a text that says:

"Bitch Can't see you, but I do. Tonight's the night I kill you.
-A"

What a coincidence that Aria in this episode said something almost identical to the a text that A sent the girls. Almost like they have the same mind and think so much alike that they could be the same person! It wouldn't surprise me if they were!


Songs in this Episode

  •  Say Goodbye by Norah Jones   Ezra & Aria in his car 
  •  Gone by Lianne La Havas   Spencer & Toby kissing
  •  Mind Games by Leagues   Aria meets with Meredith to apologize for what she and Alison did.
  •  To Have It All by Bosshouse Music    Ezra tutoring Emily at the Brew.
  •  Electric by Bosshouse Music Song  Emily is listening to  headphones
  •   Lean On Me by Bosshouse Musi     Ezra tutoring Emily at the Brew.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter @pllariatheory